All Eyes on the Court of Appeal

CCHR Report – Fair Trial Rights in Cambodia, Monitoring of the Court of Appeal

The right to be judged fairly and impartially by an independent court is an absolute right that should never be violated. However, in Cambodia fair trial rights have long been an area of concern and with recent legislation having further weakened the independence of the judiciary; a heavy spotlight should be on the courts, judges and prosecutors.

CCHR’s Trial Monitoring Project has provided that spotlight since 2009 and has since built a bridge of dialogue between the courts and civil society to address individuals’ rights violations. The report released today by CCHR is the result of data gathered from 204 cases CCHR team monitored at the Court of Appeal in the past year and highlights the challenges individuals face regarding their right to a fair trial.

The report finds the most pressing concerns to be within the area of the individual’s right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty. The data shows a practice where this norm is reversed as defendants often appear in convicted prison uniforms; presenting them as guilty before trial. This is further fueled by a number of cases where defendants are absent in their own court cases, unable to present a defense. In addition, the quality of evidence presented in hearings is often poor and threatens the right to be convicted beyond a reasonable doubt. Finally, judges are systematically failing to explain the nature of fair trial rights to the defendant, making it difficult for defendants to challenge violations of their rights.

However, while judges are failing to explain their rights to defendants, they are successfully informing them of the existence of their rights; strengths such as these show just how easy it could be to improve parts of the justice system. Public hearings are now almost fully guaranteed with the Court of Appeal posting public hearing notices outside courtrooms. The report also finds that defendants are given adequate time to prepare a defense.

With these strengths in place, the recommendations made by CCHR are realistic and achievable. Simple logistical improvements between detention centers and the Court of Appeal could eliminate the serious problem of defendants appearing in convicted uniforms; or not appearing at all. The Court of Appeal still faces challenges in guaranteeing the right to a fair trial; especially with the recent  three laws on the Judiciary adopted by the Parliament which undermine the independence of the courts; but these challenges can be overcome through cooperation with civil society and the courts to encourage and promote reform among the judiciary itself.

Lale Kuzu, CCHR International Intern, contributed to this post. 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s